The first 4 green lights indicate you have the correct controller. The yellow light says the throttle is wide open, that's where I would look.
I don't know if you have the diagnostics for the NPX4844. If this doesn't help, call Alltrax 541-476-3565, they are great with support:
LED Status Indicator:
The LED located on the front of the unit provides status of the units operation
and used for troubleshooting.
The LED Blink Codes occur at power up, the number of green blinks indicates
the throttle configuration:
* 1 Green LED flash = 0-5 kohm resistive
* 4 Green LED flashes = EZ-GO inductive (ITS)
* 7 Green LED flashes = ClubCar 5k-0 ohms, 3-wire throttle
Normal display status:
* Solid Green: Controller ready to run
* Solid Red: Controller in programming mode (not for field use)
* Solid Yellow: Controller throttle is wide open, controller is supplying
max output, and is not in current limit.
Trouble Shooting:
Error code display:# of RED blinks indicates any error conditions that might
exist:
1 Red = Throttle Position Sensor Over Range. Check for open wires.
2 Red = Under Temperature. Controller below -25C
3 Red = HPD. Throttle hasn't gone to zero during this power on cycle.
4 Red = Over Temperature. Controller over 95C
5 Red = Not used
6 Red = Battery Under Voltage detected. Battery V < under voltage slider
7 Red = Battery Over Voltage detected. Battery V > over voltage slider